Michigan, United States
Bay Pizzeria offers pizza delivery and takeout in Suttons Bay, MI. Known for fresh toppings and seasoned crusts, with convenient parking and no-contact delivery options.
4.6 / 5
Guest rating
45
Reviews
Pizza Delivery
Cuisine
Michigan
City
$10–20
Price level
Closed
Bay Pizzeria serves a variety of pizzas and subs with an emphasis on fresh toppings and well-seasoned crusts. The restaurant is a popular spot for those looking for delivery or takeout options in Suttons Bay, Michigan.
Located at 100 Cedar St, it offers a casual dining experience without indoor seating but provides some outdoor tables. The menu includes items like calzones, meatball subs, and cheese bread, appealing to those seeking hearty and flavorful meals.
Service options include no-contact delivery, delivery, and takeout, making it convenient for different preferences. The business identifies as Indigenous-owned and is committed to friendly, polite service.
Free parking is available both on-site and on nearby streets, and the facility includes wheelchair accessible parking. Payments by credit and debit card are accepted.
Grouped by category — each group lists what's available and what isn't at Bay Pizzeria.
When Bay Pizzeria is open during the week.
Closed
Central Michigan, with cafes, shops, and other restaurants within easy walking distance.
A look at the food, the dining room, drinks, and the exterior of Bay Pizzeria.
What recent guests say after dining at Bay Pizzeria.
Based on 45 guest reviews
TM E
Jun 16, 2026"The best pizza I’ve had in the Suttons Bay Area with very good crust and lots of fresh toppings. We loved the pizza sauce, too. There are many things I’d like to try here, so I’ll def be a return customer. Conveniently located close to the bike trail. A good choice on a great trail. Unfortunately no seating inside but a few tables outside."
Chris Alpers
Jun 07, 2026"Best meatball sub I’ve ever tasted. Sub ingredients are NYC deli quality. Check this place out for subs and calzones. Lilly, that works the front always has a smile on her face and is super friendly."
Angela Bowen
May 09, 2026"We had the pleasure of their pizza for dinner last night, it was pretty good, coming from me....I'm not a huge fan of pizza.....BUT...... I spied a gem in their cold case...a Pastie!!!!! Now...growing up in the Yoop, it was almost like eating my homemade pastie...yup it was that good. Good job!!!! Trust me, I'll be back...if you're in the mood for a great Pastie...hit up this place....will not disappoint.."
Douglas Welker
Apr 15, 2026"It’s worth your salt to visit Bay Pizzeria. This little joint bakes the real deal from the bubbly crust to the acre of toppings. Our most recent choice was a pepperoni/sausage combo. It was a big, bold, meat-lover’s pie. Sure, BP has competition. Shady Lane Market makes a worthy pizza. And Roman Wheel’s pies are decent (though the bottoms are greasy). As for Locals Lake Leelanau, their quality is uneven. And 9 Bean Rows can be mighty disappointing. If you want a sure thing, however, Bay Pizzeria is your best bet."
Common questions about Bay Pizzeria and its services.
Delivery, no-contact delivery, and takeout options are available to accommodate different preferences.
Indoor seating is not available, but there are a few outdoor tables for guests.
Yes, free parking is provided on-site as well as free street parking nearby, including accessible options.
Payments using credit and debit cards are accepted for customer convenience.
Wheelchair accessible parking is available, supporting improved accessibility at the location.
Many enjoy the pizza with seasoned crusts, meatball subs, calzones, and fresh toppings, though the full menu offerings may vary.
The business identifies as Indigenous-owned, contributing to the diversity of the local food scene.
The restaurant can be reached by phone at +1 231-866-4494 for orders or inquiries.
QG95+345, Jl. Malino, Romang Lompoa, Kec. Bontomarannu, Kabupaten Gowa, Sulawesi Selatan 92171, Indonesia
Río Nilo 1056, Miguel Hidalgo y Costilla, 93260 Poza Rica de Hidalgo, Ver., Mexico
4376+XV8, Jl. Wates Kediri, RT.35/RW.07, Tiris Mulyo, Wates, Kec. Wates, Kabupaten Kediri, Jawa Timur 64174, Indonesia
M2FH+MW6, Jalan Raya, Pujungan, Pupuan, Tabanan Regency, Bali 82163, Indonesia
Keep your listing accurate by updating your address, opening hours, menu, photos, and contact details. Reach more diners searching for Pizza Delivery in Michigan on Locallya.
